Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Lagos-Calabar, Sokoto-Badagry Projects: Tinubu Moves Surveyor-General’s Office To Aso Rock
    • Minister Goronyo Commissions ₦3.6bn Japanese-Donated Equipment For National Road Maintenance
    • Radio Station Closure Shows Abuse Of Power, Amnesty Tells Niger Governor
    • Yar’adua University Expels 57 Students Over Exam Malpractice
    • Marked By Culture, Judged By Society: Nigerians With Tribal Marks Speak Out On Stigma, Pride, Pain
    • NDLEA, FG To Begin Mandatory Drug Tests For 800,000 New Undergraduates From September
    • ‘Use Your Influence To Foster Unity, Not Division’, Tinubu Tells New Media Influencers
    • ‘I Don’t Belong There’, Kemi Badenoch Renounces Nigerian Identity, Says Britain Is Her Home
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    NEWS POINT NIGERIANEWS POINT NIGERIA
    UBA 720X90
    • HOME
    • NEWS

      Lagos-Calabar, Sokoto-Badagry Projects: Tinubu Moves Surveyor-General’s Office To Aso Rock

      August 2, 2025

      Minister Goronyo Commissions ₦3.6bn Japanese-Donated Equipment For National Road Maintenance

      August 2, 2025

      Radio Station Closure Shows Abuse Of Power, Amnesty Tells Niger Governor

      August 2, 2025

      Yar’adua University Expels 57 Students Over Exam Malpractice

      August 2, 2025

      Marked By Culture, Judged By Society: Nigerians With Tribal Marks Speak Out On Stigma, Pride, Pain

      August 2, 2025
    • COLUMN

      Super Falcons Deserve Every Kobo: Stop The Unnecessary Debate – By Jonathan Nda-Isaiah

      August 1, 2025

      Balkanisation, Push-Back: Can ADC Weather The Storm? – By Zainab Suleiman Okino

      July 31, 2025

      Buhari: May Our Subsequent Leaders Die At Home (2) – By Dr Hassan Gimba

      July 28, 2025

      New Wave Of Malnutrition And The Road To 2027 – By Dr Dakuku Peterside

      July 28, 2025

      Dignifying The Nigeria Police – By Kazeem Akintunde

      July 28, 2025
    • EDUCATION

      13 Countries Offering Free Or Low-Cost PhD Programmes For Non-Citizens

      January 25, 2025

      NECO: Abia, Imo Top Performing States In Two Years, Katsina, Zamfara Come Last

      October 3, 2024

      NBTE Accredits 17 Programmes At Federal Polytechnic Kabo

      August 20, 2024

      15 Most Expensive Universities In Nigeria

      May 19, 2024

      FULL LIST: Tinubu Appoints Former SGF Yayale, Ex-Governor Yuguda, Muhammad Abacha, Jega In Universities’ Governing Councils

      May 18, 2024
    • INTERNATIONAL

      ‘A Death Journey’: Palestinians Describe Aid Site Turmoil In Gaza

      August 1, 2025

      Trump Deploys Nuclear Submarines In Row With Russia’s Putin

      August 1, 2025

      Palestinian Newborns Starving In Gaza As Infant Formula Runs Out

      August 1, 2025

      Microsoft Accuses Russia’s FSB Of Using Malware Against Foreign Embassies

      August 1, 2025

      Israel Starves More Palestinians To Death In Gaza As Attacks Continue

      July 31, 2025
    • JUDICIARY

      FULL LIST: Judicial Council Recommends Appointment Of 11 Supreme Court Justices

      December 6, 2023

      Supreme Court: Judicial Council Screens 22 Nominees, Candidates Face DSS, Others

      November 29, 2023

      FULL LIST: Judicial Commission Nominates 22 Justices For Elevation To Supreme Court

      November 16, 2023

      Seven Key Issues Resolved By Seven Supreme Court Judges

      October 26, 2023

      FULL LIST: CJN To Swear In Falana’s Wife, 57 Others As SANs November 27

      October 12, 2023
    • POLITICS

      What Peter Obi May Lose If He Joins Coalition As VP Candidate

      May 25, 2025

      Atiku Moves To Unseat Wike’s Damagum As PDP Chairman, Backs Suswam As Replacement

      April 15, 2024

      Edo’s Senator Matthew Uroghide, Others Defect To APC

      April 13, 2024

      Finally, Wike Opens Up On Rift With Peter Odili

      April 2, 2024

      El-Rufa’i’s Debt Burden: APC Suspends Women Leader For Criticising Kaduna Gov

      March 31, 2024
    • SPORTS

      Adamawa Governor Gifts Super Falcons’ Coach ₦50m, House For WAFCON Victory

      August 1, 2025

      Man United Plot Blockbuster Swoop For PSG’s Goalkeeper, Donnarumma

      August 1, 2025

      Super Eagles Forward, Osimhen Completes Transfer To Galatasaray In Record €75m Deal

      August 1, 2025

      AfroBasket 2025: Nigeria’s D’Tigress To Play Cameroon In Quarter-Final

      August 1, 2025

      Nigeria’s D’Tigress Await Angola, Cameroon As 2025 Afrobasket Enters Quarterfinals

      July 31, 2025
    • MORE
      • AFRICA
      • ANALYSIS
      • BUSINESS
      • ENTERTAINMENT
      • FEATURED
      • LENS SPEAK
      • INFO – TECH
      • INTERVIEW
      • NIGERIA DECIDES
      • OPINION
      • Personality Profile
      • Picture of the month
      • Science
      • Special Project
      • Videos
      • Weekend Sports
    NEWS POINT NIGERIANEWS POINT NIGERIA
    UBA 720X90
    Home - State Creation: Another Wild Goose Chase – By Kazeem Akintunde

    State Creation: Another Wild Goose Chase – By Kazeem Akintunde

    By Kazeem AkintundeFebruary 17, 2025
    Kazeem Logo

    MEMBERS of the House of Representatives Committee on the review of the 1999 Constitution recently came up with an outlandish proposal for the creation of additional 31 states in the country. The committee, headed by the Deputy Speaker of the House, Benjamin Kalu, noted in its report to the House that if the proposal is approved, it would increase the number of states in Nigeria to 67. I found the committee’s proposal not only ridiculous, but downright insensitive.

    At a time when some of the existing 36 states are struggling to survive, some of our lawmakers are thinking of creating more states. What they intend to achieve with such creation is still unknown to me. What is however certain, is that the proposal would never become a reality. It is another wasteful voyage that our lawmakers want to embark upon to make money for themselves.

    Since the return to democratic rule in 1999, each legislative house has always reviewed the 1999 constitution and would most likely continue to, ad-infinitium. The present constitution review committee was constituted by the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Tajudeen Abbas, in February, last year. While inaugurating the committee, Abbas said that its formation would address the pitfalls that led to the failure of past Constitution Amendments by representatives working closely with the Executive at the state and Federal levels, with a promise that the current process won’t suffer the fate of previous exercises.

    UBA

    The Kalu’s committee would be the sixth Constitution Review Committee set up in the House of Representative to review the 1999 Constitution since the return to democratic governance in 1999. For the inauguration this time around, there was no committee room good enough in the National Assembly, and Abbas had to take his colleagues to the prestigious Transcorp Hilton Hotel in Abuja. The cost of the inaugural meeting would never be known to you and I.

    Now, one of the recommendations of the committee given two years to carry out its assignment is the creation of additional 31 states for the federation. How Kalu and his colleagues in the committee came up with that number is still a mystery. Perhaps, we should just adopt and convert all the 774 local governments in the country to states? In that wise, there won’t be the need for anyone to complain of marginalization again. With that, we would have succeeded in ‘spreading’ development to all the nooks and cranny of the country. At the end of the two-year period given to Kalu and his committee members, he should also be bold enough to tell Nigerians how much was spent by the committee in their desire to give Nigeria a ‘perfect’ constitution.

    WIDGET ADS

    Indeed, we have many jokers in the National Assembly. Most of them do not think deep enough to ask fundamental questions on the performance of those states already in existence in the country. The hard truth Kalu and his colleagues have failed to ask themselves is that out of the present 36-state structure and the Federal Capital Territory, we have less than 10 of those states able to stand on their own without a begging bow in their hands looking up to the all-powerful federal government for their monthly allocations. How much are the other states generating internally on a monthly basis? Can the funds that they generate take care of their basic functions, such as payment of salaries, and the running of the government? What is their wage bill on a monthly basis?

    A recent survey showed that Lagos is the most economically viable state, followed by Ogun and Rivers states. On a wider net, Kaduna, Oyo, Kwara, and Edo States are also categorised as economically viable. Again, data from the Nigerian Bureau of Statistics (NBS) and the Federal Account Allocation Committee in the 2022 Annual State Viability Index Report showed that while Lagos received N370.9bn from the Federation Account, it generated N651.2 bn internally, and Ogun State received N113.4bn from the Federation Account and generated N120.5bn from internal sources. River State received N364.4bn and generated N172bn; Kaduna received N155bn and generated N68bn; Oyo received N181bn and generated N62bn; Edo received N147bn but generated N47.4bn, and Kwara received N99bn and generated N35.7bn.

    Thomas Sankara African Leadership Prize

    The report showed that the total IGR of N1.5tn from the seven most viable states in 2022 was almost twice the total IGR of 29 states that generated N650bn. The report went further to show that six states may not even survive without the funds from the federation accounts, as they generated less than 10 per cent of what they received from federal allocations. These states are Bayelsa, Katsina, Kebbi, Akwa Ibom, Taraba and Yobe States, as most of them are unable to attract both local and foreign investments. Of course, investors do not put their money where there is low income, or where their products will not be purchased. Sadly, state governors in those states cannot play the role of catalysts in investment drive.

    With the removal of subsidy on fuel, most states now get more money in their coffers, but the recently approved minimum wage of N70,000 has taken a large chunk on the fund. In Nigeria, it is not uncommon to find many states owing their civil and public workers’ wages for many months until the Federal Government comes to their rescue, or they borrow money from local banks and secure loans from international financial institutions to carry out simple development projects.

    Nigerian TAX Reform - Federal Goverment

    The low IGR is reflective of low businesses. Most of the states are civil service states and their wages and salaries or incomes are generally irregular. Coupled with the irregular manufacture and consumption of goods, and the dearth of infrastructure against a high population across the states, some state capitals look like glorified towns and villages, leaving what the hinterland would be like to one’s imagination!

    After more than 30 years as a professional journalist, there is no state capital in the country that I have not been to, and some of them could still be described as a glorified village.

    Kalu and his committee members needs to be told that the country’s economy is not growing so exponentially as to accommodate expenses in new states. Each new state will have its bureaucracy, with state buildings and other infrastructure that will gulp huge amounts of funds that could be used to develop the modern infrastructure of the existing states.

    National Orientation Agency Page UP
    National Orientation Agency - Down

    To accommodate the new financial requirements for newly established states in the Federal Government’s financial commitment might require devaluation of the naira so that monetised oil money can go around but achieve little, given the resultant inflationary.
    Again, the little resources allocated to those states would be squandered on hotel bills and accommodation by newly elected state governors who will all move to Abuja to get federal allocations.

    Rather than embarking on a wild goose chase of balkanising the existing states, what should be our priority now is good governance at the state and local government levels, with proper accountability. America, from where we copied the presidential system of government, has only 50 states despite having a population of about 350 million. It also has 100 senators (two per state) and a total of 15 secretaries (equivalent to our Ministers). In our clime with a lesser population figure, we have 109 senators (three per state) and 360 members of the House of Representatives. Yet, we are still thinking of creating more states in a bid to make some politicians local champions at the state level.

    Currently, most states in the country have a budget of 70 to 80 per cent recurrent and merely 20 to 30 per cent capital; how can such states develop? If we must alter the constitution, it should be in the area of giving more powers from the federal to the state governors, moving responsibilities on the exclusive legislative list to the concurrent legislative lists, rejigging our leadership recruitment process to get competent and focused leaders at the state and local government levels so that they could drive development. Many states do not have a state development plan, just like the Federal Government, so there is no measurement to judge their achievements. It would be better for the legislature to close the chapter on state creation for now, if not forever, and face the task of making the current state of things to improve.

    If at all there must be state creation, it should be just one state in the south east region that have been clamouring for one more state to be at par with other regions. Even though they do not have the land nor the population, a state for the region would douse the noise of marginalisation of the zone by politicians and activists.

    However, the tough conditions laid down in the constitution for the creation of states may be an uphill task for the lawmakers as their colleagues in the Senate must concur with those in the House of Representatives, while two-third of lawmakers across the existing 36 states must also sanction the move. I do not see the current exercise going through the rigour at this period. There are pressing issues that are begging the attention of our lawmakers and state creation is not one of those.

    In ending today’s discourse, I will leave you with the admonition that came from Professor Attahiru Jega, a former Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), on the clamour for more states: ‘’I think the argument people can make is that perhaps it may bring government nearer to the people. But if you bring government nearer to the people and you do not improve governance in terms of how it addresses their needs and aspirations, what have you done? What have you achieved?

    And if you create states and the resources are not available for people to actually, or rather the governance structure is such that the resources, as little as they are, cannot be managed well, again, you don’t address the problem. What people need is for their lives and aspirations to be improved. And it can only be improved through good governance. And it is only good governance, regardless of the number of states, that can manage resources well, that can be creative to generate additional resources, and then to be able to use them efficiently and effectively to meet people’s needs and aspirations. But splitting the states, to be honest, to me, will not solve the problem. As we have seen from the history in Nigeria, the more states you create, the more you get demands for the creation of more states.”

    See you next week.

    • Akintunde is the Publisher and Editor-in-Chief of Glittersonline newspaper. His syndicated column, Monday Discourse, appears on News Point Nigeria newspaper on Mondays.

    Kazeem Akintunde's Column Reps State Creation
    Share. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn Telegram Email

    Related Posts

    Super Falcons Deserve Every Kobo: Stop The Unnecessary Debate – By Jonathan Nda-Isaiah

    August 1, 2025

    ‘Let’s Stop Playing Games’, Reps Fume At Minister As ₦5bn Baro Port Remains Unused

    August 1, 2025

    Balkanisation, Push-Back: Can ADC Weather The Storm? – By Zainab Suleiman Okino

    July 31, 2025

    Reps Propose Single-Day Voting For All 2027 Elections, Cap Campaign Spending

    July 28, 2025
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Latest Posts

    Lagos-Calabar, Sokoto-Badagry Projects: Tinubu Moves Surveyor-General’s Office To Aso Rock

    August 2, 2025

    Minister Goronyo Commissions ₦3.6bn Japanese-Donated Equipment For National Road Maintenance

    August 2, 2025

    Radio Station Closure Shows Abuse Of Power, Amnesty Tells Niger Governor

    August 2, 2025

    Yar’adua University Expels 57 Students Over Exam Malpractice

    August 2, 2025

    Marked By Culture, Judged By Society: Nigerians With Tribal Marks Speak Out On Stigma, Pride, Pain

    August 2, 2025
    Advertisement
    WIDGET ADS
    News Point NG
    © 2025 NEWS POINT NIGERIA Developed by ENGRMKS & CO.
    • Home
    • About us
    • Disclaimer
    • Our Advert Rates
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Join Us On WhatsApp