Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • We Uncovered ‘Mind-Boggling’ Corruption In NNPCL, Asset Tracing Leads To Iceland – EFCC Chairman
    • Ex-SGF Says Tinubu Didn’t Make Buhari President In 2015′, Garba Shehu’s Book Launch Sparks Historical Clarification
    • Age Falsification: Court Orders IGP To Produce Five Ex-Senior Police Officers For Arraignment
    • FG Urges US To Reconsider Visa Restrictions, Cites Impact On Bilateral Ties
    • I’m Still In PDP, Have No Intention Of Going Anywhere, Zamfara Governor Insists
    • Three Policemen, Two Soldiers Dead As Security Forces Killed 30 Bandits In Katsina
    • Ganduje Inaugurated As FAAN Board Chairman
    • Gombe Governor Reconstitutes Key Commissions, Boards; Appoints Chairmen, Members
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    NEWS POINT NIGERIANEWS POINT NIGERIA
    UBA 720X90
    • HOME
    • NEWS

      We Uncovered ‘Mind-Boggling’ Corruption In NNPCL, Asset Tracing Leads To Iceland – EFCC Chairman

      July 9, 2025

      Ex-SGF Says Tinubu Didn’t Make Buhari President In 2015′, Garba Shehu’s Book Launch Sparks Historical Clarification

      July 9, 2025

      Age Falsification: Court Orders IGP To Produce Five Ex-Senior Police Officers For Arraignment

      July 9, 2025

      FG Urges US To Reconsider Visa Restrictions, Cites Impact On Bilateral Ties

      July 9, 2025

      I’m Still In PDP, Have No Intention Of Going Anywhere, Zamfara Governor Insists

      July 9, 2025
    • COLUMN

      There Is Pain Behind That Smile. Just Do Your Bit – By Dr Hassan Gimba

      July 6, 2025

      What Can Nigeria Learn From China’s Electricity Revolution? – By Dr Dakuku Peterside

      July 6, 2025

      Amaechi: Nigerian Politicians And Doublespeak – By Kazeem Akintunde

      July 6, 2025

      Remembering ‘Watergate Scandal’ And Danger Of Crippling Opposition – By Martins Oloja

      July 6, 2025

      Don’t Kill Yourself Because He’s Cheating – By Funke Egbemode

      July 6, 2025
    • EDUCATION

      13 Countries Offering Free Or Low-Cost PhD Programmes For Non-Citizens

      January 25, 2025

      NECO: Abia, Imo Top Performing States In Two Years, Katsina, Zamfara Come Last

      October 3, 2024

      NBTE Accredits 17 Programmes At Federal Polytechnic Kabo

      August 20, 2024

      15 Most Expensive Universities In Nigeria

      May 19, 2024

      FULL LIST: Tinubu Appoints Former SGF Yayale, Ex-Governor Yuguda, Muhammad Abacha, Jega In Universities’ Governing Councils

      May 18, 2024
    • INTERNATIONAL

      UK Threatens Further Action Against Israel If Gaza Ceasefire Proposal Fails

      July 8, 2025

      Texas Flood Death Toll Passes 100 As More Bodies Recovered

      July 8, 2025

      Iran President, Masoud Pezeshkian Says Israel Attempted To Assassinate Him

      July 7, 2025

      Trump, Brazil’s Lula Clash Over Politically Charged Coup Trial

      July 7, 2025

      Israeli Army Targets Gaza City With Heavy Strikes, Killing 39

      July 6, 2025
    • JUDICIARY

      FULL LIST: Judicial Council Recommends Appointment Of 11 Supreme Court Justices

      December 6, 2023

      Supreme Court: Judicial Council Screens 22 Nominees, Candidates Face DSS, Others

      November 29, 2023

      FULL LIST: Judicial Commission Nominates 22 Justices For Elevation To Supreme Court

      November 16, 2023

      Seven Key Issues Resolved By Seven Supreme Court Judges

      October 26, 2023

      FULL LIST: CJN To Swear In Falana’s Wife, 57 Others As SANs November 27

      October 12, 2023
    • POLITICS

      What Peter Obi May Lose If He Joins Coalition As VP Candidate

      May 25, 2025

      Atiku Moves To Unseat Wike’s Damagum As PDP Chairman, Backs Suswam As Replacement

      April 15, 2024

      Edo’s Senator Matthew Uroghide, Others Defect To APC

      April 13, 2024

      Finally, Wike Opens Up On Rift With Peter Odili

      April 2, 2024

      El-Rufa’i’s Debt Burden: APC Suspends Women Leader For Criticising Kaduna Gov

      March 31, 2024
    • SPORTS

      Ahmed Musa Denies Distributing SUVs To Kano Pillars Players

      July 8, 2025

      Joao Pedro Shines As Chelsea Beat Fluminense To Reach Club World Cup Final

      July 8, 2025

      WAFCON: Babajide Pays Tribute To Jota After Scoring In Falcons’ Victory Over Tunisia

      July 7, 2025

      Arsenal Close In On Gyokeres Deal After Face-To-Face Talks

      July 7, 2025

      THROWBACK: How I Became Known As Dodo Mayana – Peter Rufai

      July 6, 2025
    • MORE
      • AFRICA
      • ANALYSIS
      • BUSINESS
      • ENTERTAINMENT
      • FEATURED
      • LENS SPEAK
      • INFO – TECH
      • INTERVIEW
      • NIGERIA DECIDES
      • OPINION
      • Personality Profile
      • Picture of the month
      • Science
      • Special Project
      • Videos
      • Weekend Sports
    NEWS POINT NIGERIANEWS POINT NIGERIA
    UBA 720X90
    Home - Appeal Court Declines Request To Ban Public Officers From Medical Treatment Abroad

    Appeal Court Declines Request To Ban Public Officers From Medical Treatment Abroad

    By Sadiq MuhammadMarch 2, 2025
    Appeal Court Abuja

    THE Court of Appeal sitting in Lagos has turned down a request by Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Femi Falana, to ban public officers from seeking medical treatment abroad.

    “It will be an infringement or breach on the Fundamental Right of Nigerians be they Public Officers or not to prevent them from seeking medical attention outside Nigeria when the need arises, and it will therefore be draconian to grant the request,” Justice Polycarp Terna Kwahar who read the judgment on behalf of the three man panel of justices held.

    The other justices of the court, Justice Mohammed Mustapha and Justice Paul Bassi, agreed and affirmed the judgment of the Federal High Court, Ikeja delivered on January 10, 2021.

    UBA

    In July 2010, Mr Falana had dragged the Federal Government before the trial court seeking among other things a declaration that Nigerians are entitled to the best attainable state of physical and mental health as guaranteed by law and the failure of the Government to repair and equip public hospitals and medical centres in Nigeria constitutes a violation of the right to protect the health of Nigerians and to ensure that they receive medical attention when they are sick.

    He sought a court order directing the government to repair and equip the hospitals and an order restraining public officials from accessing medical checkups in any foreign hospital and being treated at public expense in such hospitals.

    WIDGET ADS

    The trial court, after considering the issues, struck out the suit on the ground that the provision of adequate medical and health facilities is “not justiciable” by virtue of section 6 (6) (C) of the constitution.

    Dissatisfied with this judgment, Falana appealed in 2021 and in a unanimous judgment delivered Jan. 30th, 2025, the court of appeal agreed with the trial court that, “the right to adequate medical facilities in Nigeria is part of the Fundamental Objective and Directive Principles of State Policy,” and is therefore “non justiciable”.

    Thomas Sankara African Leadership Prize

    The court of appeal noted that while before the trial Court, Mr Falana demonstrated the ill-equipped nature of public hospitals in Nigeria and the resultant effect of the untimely deaths emanating from this lackadaisical disposition of government.

    Mr Falana had posited that he could lose his life if he fell sick since the hospitals in Nigeria cannot attend to serious health ailment or challenges but the court of appeal in it’s judgment held that despite the issue of inadequate medical facilities in the country, worrisome as it is, the law must take its course.

    Nigerian TAX Reform - Federal Goverment

    The court also said that “It is very obvious that the right to adequate medical facilities does not come under Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution [as amended], so It will therefore be anachronistic to leapfrog this human right into fundamental right.”

    The judgment reads in part: “Notwithstanding that there are cases where the right to life is expanded to include the right to food and shelter, however, since the issue before me is on medical or health matters, I shall not go on frolic to analyse the issue of right to food and shelter in this appeal. How would the matter of Public Officers treatment outside Nigeria be an issue that is linked with the fundamental right of the Appellant!” The question to ask is, what does fundamental right means?

    The Court said that “A fundamental right is a right guaranteed in the Constitution. Fundamental rights’ means any of the fundamental rights provided for in Chapter IV of the Constitution and includes any of the rights stipulated in the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (Ratification and Enforcement) Act 2004.”

    National Orientation Agency Page UP
    National Orientation Agency - Down

    “Merely entrenching a right in the 1999 Constitution does not automatically make such a right ‘fundamental right’.

    “Of all the cases referred to by the Appellant, none of them has any link with our jurisprudence. They are all from India, and this court is not bound to follow them. Persuasive as they are, I refuse to follow those cases as highlighted below:

    “(a) Paschin Banga Kher Mazdouer Samity V. State of West Bengel (1996) 4 SCL.
    “(b) Pt Parmanand Katara V. Union of India &Ors (1989) CS 2039.
    “(c) Consumer Education and Research Centres & Ors V. Union of India.

    “On the contrary, it will be an infringement or breach on the Fundamental Right of Nigerians, be they Public Officers or not, to prevent them from seeking medical attention outside Nigeria when the need arises, this Court will therefore be draconian to grant the prayers.

    “Although the averment of the Applicant/Appellant were not controverted at the trial court by the Respondent, this court been a court of justice, looked at the affidavit of the Appellant at the lower court and the facts therein do not fly with the extant laws on fundamental right so cannot be swept under the carpet, since doing otherwise will be going against judicial precedent and against the settled principle of stare decisis.

    “This application brought by the appellant seeks to import into Chapter IV what was not and is not provided for, granting the prayers in this appeal will be a travesty of justice. The lower Court did a very perfect Constitutional Law analysis and rightly too, by explaining the difference between economic, social and cultural rights since these Human Rights fall under Chapter II of the 1999 Constitution and not under Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution.” I find no merit in this appeal, I dismiss the appeal and affirm the Ruling delivered by the Federal High Court, Ikeja on the 10ht January, 2011.

    “I make no orders as to cost.”

    In a statement made available to the press Sunday afternoon, Falana in his reaction to the judgment, said that “the Court of Appeal failed to appreciate that it is discriminatory to allow a few public officers to seek medical treatment abroad while the millions of poor citizens are allowed to die in ill-equipped local hospitals.”

    Falana further said, “The Court equally failed to realise that the fundamental right to life is incomplete without the protection of the right to health by the federal, state, and local governments in Nigeria. I will certainly challenge the erroneous judgment of the Court of Appeal at the Supreme Court on account of the constitutional guarantee of right to life and equality before the law”.

    Appeal Court Medical Treatment Public Officers
    Share. Facebook Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn Telegram Email

    Related Posts

    We Uncovered ‘Mind-Boggling’ Corruption In NNPCL, Asset Tracing Leads To Iceland – EFCC Chairman

    July 9, 2025

    Ex-SGF Says Tinubu Didn’t Make Buhari President In 2015′, Garba Shehu’s Book Launch Sparks Historical Clarification

    July 9, 2025

    Age Falsification: Court Orders IGP To Produce Five Ex-Senior Police Officers For Arraignment

    July 9, 2025

    FG Urges US To Reconsider Visa Restrictions, Cites Impact On Bilateral Ties

    July 9, 2025
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Latest Posts

    We Uncovered ‘Mind-Boggling’ Corruption In NNPCL, Asset Tracing Leads To Iceland – EFCC Chairman

    July 9, 2025

    Ex-SGF Says Tinubu Didn’t Make Buhari President In 2015′, Garba Shehu’s Book Launch Sparks Historical Clarification

    July 9, 2025

    Age Falsification: Court Orders IGP To Produce Five Ex-Senior Police Officers For Arraignment

    July 9, 2025

    FG Urges US To Reconsider Visa Restrictions, Cites Impact On Bilateral Ties

    July 9, 2025

    I’m Still In PDP, Have No Intention Of Going Anywhere, Zamfara Governor Insists

    July 9, 2025
    Advertisement
    WIDGET ADS
    News Point NG
    © 2025 NEWS POINT NIGERIA Developed by ENGRMKS & CO.
    • Home
    • About us
    • Disclaimer
    • Our Advert Rates
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Join Us On WhatsApp